BASE http://ndbc.noaa.gov/ NOTES Reference: Handbook of Automated Data Quality Control Checks and Procedures of the National Data Buoy Center, 2009. SENSORS D; DIR BUOY; Directional Buoy; BASE N; NON-DIR; Non-directional Buoy; BASE TESTS SECTION: TIME SERIES VALUES D,N; RANGE CHECK (TS); verify that values fall within established ranges. SECTION: SPECTRAL VALUES D,N; MESSAGE CHECK; verify checksums, parity of transmission. D,N; RANGE CHECK (SP); check range of spectral wave density values. D,N; TIME CONTINUITY (SP); check continuity of spectral values over 1 hour. SECTION: PARAMETER VALUES D,N; RANGE CHECK (PM); check range of primary and ancillary parameters. D,N; TIME CONTINUITY (PM); check continuity of parameter values over time. D,N; LOW ENERGY; set parameters to zero for very low energy readings. D,N; HEIGHT VS. PERIOD; check that Hs does not exceed limits for the given Ta. D,N; WIND/WAVE ENERGY; checks that wave energy corresponds to measured wind. D; WIND/WAVE DIRECTION; checks that wave, wind directions correspond. D; SWELL DIRECTION; verifies that swell comes from non-sheltered directions. D; CHECK FACTORS; range test of directional wave check factors. D,N; VISUAL INSPECTION; data quality checks and procedures by analysts. DETAILS RANGE CHECK (TS) Checks that the values of the acceleration or displacement time series fall within established ranges and that the mean value falls between the minimum and maximum values of the time series. Data are not released or archived if the Range Check for Time Series fails. END MESSAGE CHECK Checks that the data encoded for transmission fall within expected ranges, that checksums match, and the transmission does not contain parity errors. Failure of the Message Check prevents the release and archive of the data. END RANGE CHECK (SP) Checks that the Spectral Wave Densities are within appropriate ranges. Failure of the Spectrum Range Check prevents the release and archive of the data. END TIME CONTINUITY (SP) Checks that the change within time of the Spectral Wave Densities for frequency bands above 0.08 Hz do not change more 0.006f-4 m2/Hz in one hour. Data are flagged for further review and released. END RANGE CHECK (PM) Checks that the values for wave parameters, Significant Wave Height and Dominant Period are within limits determined by climatology. The Range Check for the Significant Wave Height is dependent on the Time Continuity check for the previous hour. This dependency prevents the Range Check failures during extreme events. Failure of the Range Check prevents the release of the data in real-time and will prevent the data from being archived unless the failure is removed by an analyst.

Monthly Range Check: Checks that the values for wave parameters, Significant Wave Height and Dominant Period, are within limits determined by monthly seasonal climatology. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst.

Ancillary Data Range Checks: Parameters such as buoy tilt, difference between the buoy heading determined from the wave system magnetometers and the heading from the wind compasses, the directional spreading, and the wave system earth magnetic flux are checked to be within ranges established by experience. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst.

Related Measurement Failure: Significant Wave Height and Dominant Period are considered related measurements and the failure of Range or Time Continuity checks cause of one causes the failure of the other and thus not released and not archived. Significant Wave Height is related to Mean Wave Direction (if available) û the failure of Significant Wave height causes the failure of Mean Wave Direction, however the failure of Mean Wave Direction does not cause failure of Significant Wave Height. Related Measurement Failure prevents the release of the data in real-time and will prevent the data from being archived unless the failure is removed by an analyst. END TIME CONTINUITY (PM) Checks that the change with time of Significant Wave Height are within limits determined by climatology. Failure of the Time Continuity Check prevents the release of the data in real-time and will prevent the data from being archived unless the failure is removed by an analyst.

Monthly Time Continuity: Checks that the change with time of Significant Wave Height and Dominant Period are within limits determined by monthly or seasonal climatology. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst.

Related Measurement Failure: Significant Wave Height and Dominant Period are considered related measurements and the failure of Range or Time Continuity checks cause of one causes the failure of the other and thus not released and not archived. Significant Wave Height is related to Mean Wave Direction (if available) û the failure of Significant Wave height causes the failure of Mean Wave Direction, however the failure of Mean Wave Direction does not cause failure of Significant Wave Height. Related Measurement Failure prevents the release of the data in real-time and will prevent the data from being archived unless the failure is removed by an analyst. END LOW ENERGY If the significant wave height is less than 0.15 m, the Significant Wave Height, Dominant Period and Average Period are adjusted to zero and the Mean Wave Direction is considered missing. The Wave Periods are set to zero to prevent large swings of periods occurring because of the low energy values. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst. END HEIGHT VS. PERIOD Wave Height Verses Average Wave Period: Checks whether the Wave Height exceeds threshold values (hmax) which are based on a functions of the Average Period (AVGPD). The functions are:

    For AVGPD <= 5 s:       hmax = 2.55 + (AVGPD / 4)

    For AVGPD > 5 s:         hmax = (1.16 * AVGPD) - 2

NDBC computes AVGPD as the square root of the ratio of the zeroth spectral moment to the second spectral moment. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst. END WIND/WAVE ENERGY Wind and Wave Relationship Test: Checks that the wave energy exceeds pre-established limits based on the square of a four-hour average wind speed. A statistical wind-wave comparison algorithm established a relationship between sum of the Spectral Wave Densities at high frequencies (0.20 through 0.27 Hz) during the current hour with the mean of the square of the wind speeds for the current and the previous three hours. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst. For further information, see Norman Lang, 1987, An algorithm for the quality checking of wind speeds measured at sea against wave spectral energy., IEEE J. of OCEAN. ENG., OE-12(4), pp. 560-567. END WIND/WAVE DIRECTION Wave Direction Verses Wind Direction Test: Checks that the Mean Wave Direction at 0.35 Hz is within 25 degrees of the wind direction when the wind speed is greater than 7 m/s, and the wind direction has not varied by more than 30 degrees since the previous report, and the Spectral Wave Density at 0.35 Hz is greater than 0.003 m2/Hz. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by an analyst. END SWELL DIRECTION For buoys near the coast, checks that the mean wave directions (alpha1) for the frequency bands 0.03 to 0.10 Hz do not originate from sheltered or limited fetch directions. Spectral Wave Densities must be both greater then 0.5 m2/Hz and at least 5 percent of the Spectral Wave Density of the band with the highest Spectral Wave Density. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst. END CHECK FACTORS Directional Wave Check Factor: Range check of the Check Factors at 0.1, 0.2, and 0.35 Hz. Data are flagged for further review and released and the data are archived unless rejected by analyst. END VISUAL INSPECTION Data Quality Checks and Procedures by Expert Analysts by the National Data Buoy Center:

Visual inspection may result in the removal of measurements from the archives or the restoration of measurements removed by the automated procedures.

  • Daily: Review time series plots and nearest neighbor comparisons of wave parameters (Significant Wave Height, Dominant Period, Mean Wave Direction, Wind Wave Height, Period, and Direction, Swell Height, Period, and Direction).

  • Monthly: Review plots of the sum of the high frequency Spectral Wave Densities (0.30 through 0.35 Hz) versus square of the average of the four-hour wind speed for stations with 3-meter hulls. For further information, see Palao and Gilhousen, The Re-derivation of the NDBC Wind Wave Algorithm in Ocean Wave Measurement and Analysis, Proceedings of the Second International Symposium, published by the American Society of Civil Engineers, 1993, pp 569-575.

  • As needed: Comparison with National Center for Environmental Prediction's WAVEWATCH III wave parameters.
  • END